Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Awesome Onion Rings
A Sausage Link
Loaded Mesquite Grilled Chicken Breast
Bar-B-Q Chicken
About
Brother Bruno's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Welcome to Brother Bruno's Pizzeria & Restaurant, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Middletown, NY, at 125 Dolson Ave. This beloved local establishment expertly blends tradition with modern flair in its Italian offerings, showcasing a mouthwatering selection of pizzas and sandwiches that beckon food lovers from near and far.
Brother Bruno's is not just a restaurant; it's a culinary experience that celebrates the essence of Italian cuisine. Whether you're in the mood for a classic pizza loaded with your favorite toppings or wishing to indulge in a hearty sandwich, this family-friendly pizzeria has something for everyone. The casual atmosphere, complemented by its divey yet inviting decor, makes it an ideal spot for gatherings, celebrations, or a quick weeknight dinner.
One of the standout features of Brother Bruno's is its commitment to inclusivity. The menu boasts a plethora of vegetarian options, ensuring that every palate is satisfied. Furthermore, the restaurant is wheelchair accessible and welcomes customers traveling with their dogs, making it a truly accommodating place for all diners. Plus, with features like outdoor seating, happy hour specials, and reliable Wi-Fi, it’s easy to see why it’s a hit among locals.
- Signature Dishes: The selection of pizzas offered is a highlight. Many regulars rave about the "best pizza in the Middletown area," and the reviews speak volumes about the consistent quality and flavor.
- Customer Favorites: The 2 Meat Salad and the Chicken Caesar Salad are both crowd-pleasers. Patrons appreciate the fresh ingredients and generous portions, perfect for a refreshing yet filling meal.
- BBQ Delights: For those looking for something different, the BBQ chicken and ribs are show-stoppers that keep diners coming back for more!
Numerous commendations pour in from delighted customers, with praises ranging from quick service to the warm, inviting atmosphere. Reviewers like Jennifer A. have called it “the king of the castle” in pizza, praising the consistency and excellence found in each dish. Meanwhile, Yan D. expertly encapsulated the popular sentiment that every slice is a delightful journey.
With options for takeout, delivery, and even catering, Brother Bruno's Pizzeria & Restaurant makes it easy to enjoy a slice of Italy, wherever you are. Perfect for lunch, dinner, or a relaxing meal with friends and family, it's clear—this is a place that transforms ordinary dining into an extraordinary experience.
So why wait? Experience the magic of Brother Bruno's for yourself! Give them a call at (845) 343-1550 to place your order or come over, unwind, and indulge in the flavors that make it a must-visit destination.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ In my opinion best pizza in the Middletown Area. In the pizza mood definitely stop by for a slice or few. - Anton Ego approves ”
“ They're quick, pizza is good, and they are easy to deal with at the counter. Bring cash if you spend less than $20 or just order 2 of any 2-liter bottles of soda and a large pie and you are set. I haven't tried anything else so can't speak to their menu but I'd be down one day. ”
“ Good food with large potions in a casual walking setting. Order at the counter, grab a seat, and your food is out quickly! ”
“ The king of the castle right here! Brother Brunos's is the OGD when it comes to delicious pizza. You will never get a bad pie or sandwich from these guys. And their service is killer too,. Thank you, Brother Brunos, for your consistency and for always serving the best of the best. ”
“ The pizza by the slice was a true 5 stars. I was just here (Sunday 5-26-24). This was REAL pizza and a REAL value. My menu pictures are from May of 2024. This will be a regular restaurant for me to stop at. ”
“ Cheese and pepperoni pizza was great. Garlic knots were some of the better ones I've tried, very soft. Also they threw in some kind of dessert. It was like a sugar powder dough thing and it was great! I ordered delivery and it took a little long so I called to check on it and the staff was extremely kind and helpful and even called back to check in that we received our order. Great customer service! ”
“ My supervisor suggested we try their "Gramma Pizza" so I called and ordered it. I went in to pick it up and when I saw all the Halloween decorations, I knew this was a place that cares. I asked if I could take a photo of their Adam and Barbara decorations because I'm such a huge fan of Bettlejuice - the two very friendly men behind the counter welcomed me to look around and have fun. I'm assuming they are the owners and both were so warm and very welcoming! The Gramma Pizza is beyond delicious! The crust is crispy and not at all chewy. The sauce is seasoned well, not too sweet or acidic. The flavor of garlic and basil is the perfect combination. The mozzarella is plentiful and accents the pizza well. I took a menu with me and I'm looking forward to trying more items on their menu!! ”
